The Party Idea Playbook
Illustration of halloween bake-off

Halloween bake-off

HalloweenAll agesBudget costEasy effortIndoorAny gender

Families decorate spooky cupcakes, cookies and a graveyard cake in a timed bake-off with silly prizes.

Guests
6-20 guests
Party length
2-3 hours
Prep time
Half a day (baking in advance)
Ages
All ages

What it could look like

Save to Pinterest
AI-generated example of a halloween bake-off
An example of how a halloween bake-off could look on the day. This image was generated by AI.

What it is

A decorating competition for families. The baking is done ahead, so the party is all about turning cupcakes, cookies and cakes into monsters, mummies and graveyards. Every team wins a silly prize.

Plan ahead

  • The day before: bake cupcakes (6 per team), sugar cookies (in ghost, bat and pumpkin shapes) and a chocolate traybake per team. Make buttercream in orange, green, purple and black.
  • On the day: put out decorating bowls: edible eyes, sprinkles, sweets, chocolate fingers and crushed biscuits.

Rounds

  1. Monster cupcakes: green buttercream hair, lots of eyes, sweet teeth.
  2. Spooky cookies: white icing ghosts, mummies (zig-zag icing lines with two eyes), orange pumpkins.
  3. Graveyard cake: chocolate traybake with crushed biscuit “soil”, biscuit gravestones with icing names, gummy worms and marshmallow ghosts.

Judging

Prizes for “scariest”, “silliest”, “most eyes”, “best mummy” and “most edible”.

Food and drink

  • Savoury food to balance: pizza, sausage rolls
  • Witch’s brew punch
  • Everyone eats their bakes

Tips

  • Cover tables with plastic - black icing stains.
  • Have a nut-free selection of decorations.

On the day

  1. Arrival (15 min): aprons on, teams of 2-4.
  2. Round 1 - Monster cupcakes (25 min).
  3. Round 2 - Spooky cookies (25 min).
  4. Snack break (15 min).
  5. Showstopper - Graveyard cake (30 min).
  6. Judging and prizes (15 min), then everyone eats.

Shopping list

halloween cupcake cases
Check price
halloween sprinkles
Check price
edible googly eyes
Check price
halloween cookie cutters
Check price
black food colouring gel
Check price
piping bags
Check price

We may earn a commission if you buy through these links, at no extra cost to you.

Party types

Birthdays by age

Who it's for

Style